Middle management is getting cut, and AI is the reason everyone gives. Some of that is true. A lot of it is a cover story.
The honest version
Flattening started before the tools got good. 2023 was the "year of efficiency," with layoff memos promising fewer layers and faster decisions. AI just gave it a better story. "We're becoming an AI-first org" plays a lot better with a board than "we hired too many people in 2021."
But part of it is real. A big chunk of the middle manager job has always been moving information around. Rolling up status. Writing the weekly update. Sitting in one meeting so you can repeat what was said in another meeting. The tools are good at that now. A year ago I wrote The AI We Were Promised and called most of it busywork automation that wasn't practical yet. That gap closed faster than I expected.
It's also worth asking who is making the call. Cory Doctorow puts it well in The Reverse Centaur's Guide to Life After AI: the important question about a technology is who it does it for and who it does it to. The people deciding to cut manager layers are rarely the ones in the layer.
Who comes out the other side
Managers who are close to the work. If you can read the PR, follow the architecture tradeoff, and call out a bad estimate before it becomes a bad quarter, you're still useful after the status report starts writing itself.
Managers whose name is on an outcome. If your name is attached to a result (the launch, the migration, the cost number), you're hard to cut. If your name is attached to a recurring calendar invite, you're easy.
Managers who make people better. Coaching, hard conversations, hiring well, keeping a good engineer from quitting. No tool does that, and leadership tends to underrate it until it's gone.
Audit your own week
Pull up last week's calendar and sort every hour into three buckets: passing information along, making a decision, or working with a person. Be honest about it. If the first bucket is the biggest, that's the bucket being automated, and it's better to notice that yourself than to hear it in a reorg meeting.
When I sorted my own week, most of it landed in the last two buckets. A lot of my time goes to finding the gaps, the places where something keeps falling through the cracks between people or teams, building a system to cover it, and then moving on to the next one. (The Emergency Runbook started exactly that way.) The rest is strategy and connecting people to the outcomes they're working toward. A tool can help me build the system faster. It can't tell me where the gap is.
So go look. If a tool could do most of your week, you want to find that out before your boss does.